I sit cross legged in my office chair, trying to find a yoga style position that will ease whatever it is I’ve done to my left lower lumbar region. The cat has her butt firmly planted on my left thigh while enthusiastically kneading my right knee. It seems to make her happy, and my bathrobe is thick enough to shield me from the claws this morning. A perfect cup of french press coffee steams on the desk. All is well.
Should be writing.
That is the mantra running through and through my brain. It starts when David’s alarm clock jerks us both out of the warm drowse of sleep and into a harsh reality of work and parental responsibilities. It mutters at me while I’m loading the French Press and making coffee. Sneers when I sit down here to send out an early morning Twitter message and discover my fingers are not yet capable of typing words recognizable in the English language. Or any language, for that matter, except for that of the sleep deprived.
Should be writing.
Thinking it now while I’m WRITING words here. Thinking it while WRITING morning pages in my journal. And later, I’ll be thinking it while driving kids around, tidying up the house, working with people at my job.
Should. The language of guilt.
Should is not an action verb. It is never motivating. It is a sneaky, manipulative word that leads along a path of regret, self doubt, and perfectionism. And the end thereof is a wasteland of books unwritten, dreams unpursued, moments of life unlived.
The other day, while I was sitting in an airport, bored and waiting for my flight, I opened my laptop and thought about writing. (I should write. I should). But the flight was boarding in half an hour and I really didn’t want to delve into the WIP. So I did something I haven’t done in years – started writing descriptions of the people around me.
During that half hour something happened. I don’t remember the other faces I saw around me that day. But the three directly across from me, and the one sleeping on the floor – I know exactly what they looked like, what they were wearing, what they carried with them. A sense of them lingers with me still. Writing made them real to me.
Should has kept me from that kind of writing. I think it keeps me from writing here as well.
Lately I’ve been thinking about my writing a lot – remembering the joy of it. Writing to tell a story without wondering with every chapter, every character that shows up in my head -”what genre is this? Can I sell it?” And I wonder if it’s possible to forget about all of the shoulds and just be a writer.
Writer: one who writes. One who writes to make sense of the world, to make bits and pieces of it real enough to fit on the page. Maybe, if I’m lucky, to frame a piece of my reality in words or story that will also mean something to people who read. For right now, the day waits. I can’t tell the shape of it yet, although there are a few landmarks I know to expect. And maybe, just maybe, I’ll pause somewhere in the middle of this day – not to write what I think I should – but just to capture a moment, a person, a time, a place – and put it on the page.
Not because I should. Because I choose.

8 comments
Comments feed for this article
October 19, 2010 at 6:28 am
Brittany Landgrebe
I hate the word “should” too. Whenever I hear it, the teenage part of me wants to do the opposite, and filters through the adult in me into lethargy and lack of concentration.
I really need to try just writing in the morning. Or at the very least, do some free sketching while my mind wakes up. I forget to enjoy the flow from sleep to wake like I used to, you know? Wake up, putter around without any lights on, make my tea (or coffee), and watch the sky lighten while I free draw or write.
Thanks for the reminder to do what I choose and not what I should!
^_^
October 19, 2010 at 6:53 am
Linda G.
This is a fantastic post.
I hate the word “should.” It is an inspiration killer. With my writing I try to keep my mind in an “Oh, boy, I get to!” place as much as possible–because, I remind myself, I don’t have to write. Nobody is holding a gun to my head.
Sure, the shoulds creep in sometimes, in spite of that. When they do, I pick up somebody else’s book and read until they go away.
October 19, 2010 at 7:55 am
Jeffe Kennedy
Oddly similar to my post today (shocking!). It’s a fine line to draw, between the fun aspect and the job aspect. But you’re right – no one ever says “I *should* ride the roller coaster.”
October 19, 2010 at 8:02 am
Kelly Breakey
The day waits. I love that because knowing that makes it possible to believe it can be any kind of day I want it to be. Even one filled with writing, not because I should, but because I choose to.
Excellent post Kerry!
October 19, 2010 at 12:13 pm
Silver James
Yes. This. Every writer in the hunt for publication hits this wall. At what point to you set aside the passion and settle for the mundane? Hopefully, you never do. To write something someone will read and remember means leaving part of yourself on that page. Writing–GOOD writing requires heart. Writing because you should sucks the life out of it. Write because you want to, because you *have* to, not because you think your current WIP will be the next NYT best seller.
For me personally, I think some authors fall into the easy trap of writing the same book over and over because it sold the first time. They file off the serial numbers, change the names to protect the guilty, and voilà–they have a saleable book. But to me, as a reader, this is a big disservice. But maybe I read for different reasons from other people. I want to fall in love with the words on the page, with the characters, and with the story.
Anyway, before I ramble completely away from the point, I’ll stop here. Find your passion, Kerry, and write from there.
October 31, 2010 at 5:47 am
gypsyscarlett
Great post, Kerry.
Now that you’ve discovered the evils of “should”- you can banish it.
November 1, 2010 at 6:55 pm
Joe Conley
Currently, even though it’s November, I’m writing because I choose to. And as it so happens, I am enjoying myself. Quite a lot.
November 1, 2010 at 7:21 pm
Kerry Schafer
Joe! So good to see you. The fact that you are writing makes me very happy. : )